Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Crime & Courts

High Court Bars Mudimu Law Chambers From Mining Dispute Over Conflict of Interest

Mentally Ill Murder Suspect Abandoned by Family

The High Court has disqualified Mudimu Law Chambers from representing Huzodi Investments Private Limited in an ongoing mining dispute, citing a conflict of interest.

The decision was made following objections raised by one of the respondents, Mr. Giveus Mutombo, who argued that the firm’s senior partner, Mr. Mudimu, had previously represented him in a related criminal case, gaining access to confidential information that could now be used against him.

Huzodi Investments filed a lawsuit against several parties, including Mr. Giveus Mutombo, Mr. Ken Mutombo, Zhang Qing, Lius Skeng Keng, and the Minister of Mines. However, Mr. Mutombo opposed Mr. Mudimu’s involvement in the case, highlighting that the lawyer had acted as his representative during a criminal case at the Bindura Magistrates’ Court related to the same mine at the center of the civil dispute.

Through his lawyers, Advocate Garikayi Sithole and Mr. Madlabe, Mr. Mutombo expressed concerns that Mr. Mudimu’s prior access to sensitive information could unfairly disadvantage him in the current proceedings.

“It was shocking to discover that Mudimu Law Chambers was now representing the opposing party in this matter,” said Mr. Mutombo, calling the situation a clear conflict of interest.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Despite arguments by Advocate Keith Kachambwa, representing Huzodi Investments, that no privileged information had been identified, Justice Gibson Mandaza sided with the respondent. The court found a strong connection between the criminal and civil cases, both stemming from the same mine.

Although Mr. Mudimu had renounced his agency in August 2024, the court ruled this step was insufficient and untimely.

“By the time Mr. Mudimu renounced his agency, the damage had already been done,” said Justice Mandaza, who upheld the preliminary objection and ordered Mudimu Law Chambers to withdraw from the case.

“Accordingly, I cannot allow Mudimu Law Chambers to continue representing the applicant (Huzodi). It is so ordered that Mr. Mudimu and his law firm cease acting for the applicant forthwith,” ruled Justice Mandaza.

Justice Mandaza emphasized the legal profession’s ethical obligations, particularly the need to avoid conflicts of interest and protect client confidences.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

“In the present case, having acted for the second respondent, it was incumbent upon Mr. Mudimu to advise the applicant to seek alternative legal representation,” he stated.

The court further underscored that conflicting interests include those of former clients and highlighted the ethical duty of lawyers to preserve confidences even after a professional relationship ends.

“This duty extends to all partners within a law firm. Courts have consistently expressed disdain for legal practitioners who represent opposing litigants in disputes.”

For comments, Feedback and Opinions do get in touch with our editor on WhatsApp: +44 7949 297606.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Catch More Updates Below

LOCAL NEWS

The government has intervened and ordered the Harare City Council to immediately halt its controversial house demolition program, which had sparked widespread public outrage....

LOCAL NEWS

The Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC) party, led by Jameson Timba, faced a setback in its bid to claim ZiG 22.1 million under the...

LOCAL NEWS

The High Court has mandated an end to alluvial mining activities in Penhalonga, Manicaland province, following a legal challenge by local residents aimed at...

LOCAL NEWS

In a landmark ruling, two High Court judges have affirmed the right of mentally ill persons to engage in consensual sexual relationships and that...

Celeb Gossip

Aaron Chaka, who asserts that he is the son of the late Oliver “Tuku” Mtukudzi, has lost his legal bid to adopt the Mtukudzi...

LOCAL NEWS

The High Court has rejected an appeal by 73 members of the opposition CCC, including former MP and minister Jameson Timba, who sought bail...

LOCAL NEWS

President Emmerson Mnangagwa has appointed ten new High Court judges and one judge for the Administrative Court, following the recommendation of the Judicial Service...

LOCAL NEWS

The North Gauteng High Court in Pretoria has issued interdict barring the South African Revenue Service (SARS) from installing CCTV cameras at tobacco-manufacturing warehouses....

Advertisement