Connect with us

Hi, what are you looking for?

Sports News

Highlanders Vice Captain Peter ’21 Questions’ Muduhwa Found Guilty

Highlanders Vice Captain Peter ’21 Questions’ Muduhwa Found Guilty

HIGHLANDERS vice captain and defender Peter ’21 Questions’ Muduhwa was found guilty by the Premier Soccer League disciplinary committee for failing to protect match officials against acts or attempted acts of violence or any other form of abuse before, during or after a match.

According to the judgement, allegations are that on the 10th of September 2023 at Barbourfields Stadium during a League match between Highlanders FC and Dynamos FC, the referee reported that “as we got into the dressing room entrance, Highlanders player number 21.

Mudhuwa Peter stopped us from entering the dressing room shouting “Lingabavuleli batshiyeni betshaywe” (Don’t open for them, leave them so that they are beaten)”

It was the disciplinary committee, led by Doreen Gapare who was the chairperson and members Wellington Magaya and Ralph Tsivama’s contention that Muduhwa’s actions were in contravention of Order 31 of the Castle Lager PSL Rules and Regulations which states that, it is an Act of Misconduct on the part of a player who; 31.2.11 Fails to protect match officials against acts or attempted acts of violence or any other form of abuse before, during or after a match; 31.2.16 Commits any act, makes any statement, either orally or in writing, or has been responsible for conduct which is considered ungentlemanly, insulting or improper behavior, or likely to bring the game or any of its sponsors, any member, the League, ZIFA, CAF or FIFA into disrepute.

Muduhwa, who was in the company of club vice chairperson Sifiso Siziba and Oppah Mpofu pleaded not guilty to the charges. He was however subsequently found guilty and fined US$500 which much be paid on or before October 17. In addition he was slaped with a four match suspension.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Below is the full judgement.

JUDGEMENT

Evidence was led from the referee Allan Bhasvi who testified to the effect that during the Chaos that ensued when there was a problem of crowd control the accused ran and instructed that the person manning the gate should not open for the referees and that they should be left to be beaten by the fans. The referee stated that he knows the accused and can positively identify him. He further stated that he has no reason to lie against him or fabricate events.

During cross examination, the player and the club representatives sought to discredit the referee as being biased and made reference to a prior incident. The referee was clear that he made all efforts to manage the tense atmosphere as it appeared that the player wanted to taunt or gourd him into making a determination or ruling that would somehow play into the narrative that the referee was biased against the accused.

The committee found the witness’ evidence to be credible and reliable. He presented his evidence in a clear and concise manner, even during cross examination by the accused. The accused sought to discredit the witness but inadvertently revealed that it was in fact he who held a grudge against the referee from their prior encounters. It can be reasonably inferred that the accused harbored some residual resentment from their previous encounters to an extent that when violence broke out he may have uttered the ungentlemanly and improper words and therefore failed to protect match officials against acts or attempted acts of violence or any other form of abuse before, during or after a match.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

Reasons for Sentence

in arriving at the appropriate sentence, we have considered the evidence and the submissions made by both parties. We have taken into account that the accused is a professional footballer who makes a living through playing football.

As a team vice- captain he is aware that players have a major responsibility to protect the image of the game and team captains play an important role in helping to ensure that the laws of the game and referees and match officials are respected.

If the accused felt that the referee had been biased against him in the past as suggested he should have followed the proper channel in lodging a protest against referee, rather than choosing to take advantage of the chaotic situation and utter such statements.

Furthermore, the accused made the statement at a time when tensions were high and there was violence and damage to property which ultimately caused the match to be abandoned.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

We are convinced that the accused indeed uttered those words or words to the like effect were uttered by him.

In arriving at the appropriate sentence, we have taken into account the fact that there

is a need to ensure that players are deterred from acting on their emotions. A threat of

violence is indeed violence. There is need, therefore, to send a very strong message to

deter such minded people.

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.

In arriving at the appropriate sentence, we stand guided by the standing orders, and the principle of consistency and uniformity.

More | ZiMetro News

For Feedback and Comments Please Contact Us On WhatsApp: +27 82 836 5828

Join Our WhatsApp Group Here

Advertisement. Scroll to continue reading.
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Catch More Updates Below

Sports News

Bulawayo, Zimbabwe | Sihlangu Dlodlo, the chief executive officer of Highlanders Football Club, was found dead on Monday evening at his residence in Nketa...

Sports News

Highlanders secured a commanding 3-0 victory over GreenFuel yesterday, advancing to the Chibuku Super Cup quarter-finals in what was one of their most dominant...

Sports News

BULAWAYO – Former Highlanders FC midfielders Eric Mudzingwa and Denzel Khumalo have reportedly been arrested with allegations of cellphone theft surfacing according to a...

Sports News

Baltemar Brito, the HIGHLANDERS coach, referred to his players as “warriors” after they shown champion-like perseverance to overcome Herentals 1-0 at Mandava yesterday. Melikhaya...

Sports News

Highlanders are now top of the Castle Lager Premier Soccer League table despite being held to a goalless draw against Sheasham at Bata Stadium...

Sports News

Matches between Dynamos and Highlanders are never friendly encounters, no matter what is at stake. And the historical Independence Trophy final at Mt darwin...

Sports News

Prince Ndlovu, a Highlanders youngster, is reportedly set to go through trials with South African top-flight club Orlando Pirates. After arriving in the country...

Sports News

Highlanders Football Club have announced their players and coaches ahead of the start of the 2023 Castle Lager Premier Soccer League season, with Joel...

Advertisement